Compare islands
Side-by-side relocation data with passport filter. Use family focus for schools and daily logistics.
Select 2–5 islands to compare
Maximum of 5 islands — deselect one to add another.
Balearic Islands
Canary Islands
U.S. Virgin Islands
Isle of Man
Galápagos Islands
St Lucia
Tasmania
Antarctic coast islands
Aleutian Islands
Andaman Islands
Scottish Islands
Hawaiian Islands
United States Islands
Remote islands
China Islands
Popular tourist islands
21 fields differ across these islands — highlighted below.
Swipe or scroll sideways to compare islands
| Field | St Thomas | St John | St Croix |
|---|---|---|---|
| Residency | |||
| Residency (US passport)differs | U.S. citizen — no visa required: U.S. citizens may live and work in the USVI without additional immigration paperwork. Territory tax benefits (Form 8898) may apply for bona fide residents. · verified 2026-06-01 | U.S. citizen — no visa required: Same as territory-wide rules. Note: limited rental inventory and higher COL than St Thomas or St Croix. · verified 2026-06-01 | U.S. citizen — no visa required: U.S. citizens may live and work freely. St Croix offers lower housing costs and the territory's only refinery-adjacent industrial economy (diversifying post-2021). · verified 2026-06-01 |
| Education | |||
| Schools (K–12)differs | Antilles School; All Saints Cathedral School; Saints Peter & Paul Catholic School verified 2026-06-01 | Julius E. Sprauve School (public); Gifft Hill School (private) verified 2026-06-01 | Good Hope Country Day School; St. Croix Educational Complex (public high school); The Manor School verified 2026-06-01 |
| Early years (preschool / nursery)differs | USVI Head Start / Early Head Start (St Thomas sites); Antilles School; All Saints Cathedral School verified 2026-06-01 | Gifft Hill School (private) verified 2026-06-01 | USVI Head Start / Early Head Start (St Croix sites); Good Hope Country Day School; The Manor School verified 2026-06-01 |
| Higher educationdiffers | University of the Virgin Islands verified 2026-06-01 | None documented on island | University of the Virgin Islands verified 2026-06-01 |
| Overview | |||
| Populationdiffers | 42,259 U.S. Census Bureau (2020 Island Areas) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | 3,881 U.S. Census Bureau (2020 Island Areas) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | 41,004 U.S. Census Bureau (2020 Island Areas) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 |
| Healthcare | |||
| Hospital on islanddiffers | Yes — full hospital on island Schneider Regional Medical Center (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | No full hospital on island — Nearest full hospital on St Thomas (20 min ferry) Schneider Regional (Myrah Keating Smith Clinic) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | Yes — full hospital on island Juan F. Luis Hospital & Medical Center (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 |
| Evacuation notesdiffers | Full-service hospital on island (Schneider Regional). Complex specialty care and some trauma cases may require airlift to San Juan, Puerto Rico or mainland U.S. Schneider Regional Medical Center (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | Urgent/primary clinic only (Myrah Keating Smith). No full hospital — emergencies typically evacuated by ferry or air to St Thomas (Schneider Regional) or San Juan. Schneider Regional Medical Center (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | Full hospital on island (Juan F. Luis). Complex cases may transfer to San Juan or mainland. Juan F. Luis Hospital & Medical Center (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 |
| Cost of living | |||
| Rent band (monthly, USD)differs | $1,605/mo (HUD 2BR FMR FY2025) HUD Fair Market Rent via RentData.org (FY2025, St. Thomas) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | $2,178/mo (HUD 2BR FMR FY2025) HUD Fair Market Rent via RentData.org (FY2025, St. John) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | $1,387/mo (HUD 2BR FMR FY2025) HUD Fair Market Rent via RentData.org (FY2025, St. Croix) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 |
| Groceries vs mainland USdiffers | 15–30% above mainland U.S. average U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (Caribbean region) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | 25–40% above mainland U.S. (fewer stores, ferry freight) U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (Caribbean region) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | 10–25% above mainland U.S. average U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (Caribbean region) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 |
| Island cost premiumdiffers | Moderate–high; most goods imported. Highest COL of the three USVI islands. U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis (USVI GDP) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | Highest of USVI trio — ~60% of island is national park; limited developable land drives housing costs. National Park Service (Virgin Islands NP) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | Lowest of the three USVI islands; more land, larger grocery selection than St John. U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis (USVI GDP) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 |
| Connectivity | |||
| Fiber availablediffers | Yes Viya (local ISP) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | No Viya (local ISP) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | Yes Viya (local ISP) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 |
| Typical internet speeddiffers | 100–500 Mbps (fiber in town areas; varies by address) Viya (local ISP) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | 25–100 Mbps (DSL/cable; fiber limited) Viya (local ISP) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | 100–500 Mbps (fiber in Christiansted/Frederiksted areas) Viya (local ISP) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 |
| Climate & risk | |||
| Hurricane / cyclone exposurediffers | High — Atlantic hurricane season (Jun–Nov). Direct hits possible; infrastructure rebuilt after 2017 storms. NOAA National Hurricane Center (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | High — exposed, less infrastructure redundancy than St Thomas. Irma/Maria caused extended outages (2017). NOAA National Hurricane Center (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | High — south of St Thomas/St John; Maria caused significant damage (2017). Season Jun–Nov. NOAA National Hurricane Center (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 |
| Daily life | |||
| Language(s)differs | English (official); Spanish widely spoken USVI Department of Tourism (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | English (official) USVI Department of Tourism (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | English (official); Crucian Creole locally USVI Department of Tourism (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 |
| Car necessitydiffers | Recommended — steep hills, limited public transit outside Charlotte Amalie USVI Department of Tourism (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | Essential — no public transit; steep roads; taxi from Cruz Bay only USVI Department of Tourism (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | Recommended — island is larger (28×15 mi); limited public transit USVI Department of Tourism (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 |
| Property | |||
| Foreign property ownershipdiffers | U.S. citizens: no restrictions. Non-U.S. citizens: subject to U.S. federal immigration status; no additional territory restriction on ownership for lawful residents. USVI real estate guidance (cross-checked with territory law) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | Same as USVI territory rules. Additional scrutiny on hillside/national park-adjacent parcels. USVI real estate guidance (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 | U.S. citizens: no restrictions. Non-U.S. citizens: U.S. federal immigration rules apply. USVI real estate guidance (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-01 |
| Demographics | |||
| Age profilediffers | Youngest USVI island — median age ~39 (2010 island district); Charlotte Amalie urban core attracts working-age service workers. U.S. Census Bureau — 2010 USVI (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | Older median age than St Thomas — affluent retirees and seasonal residents; smaller year-round school-age cohort. U.S. Census Bureau — 2010 USVI (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | Largest island population; median age ~41; more families than St John, steadier school enrollment in Christiansted/Frederiksted. U.S. Census Bureau — 2010 USVI (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Ethnic / cultural backgrounddiffers | ~71% Black, ~14% White, higher Hispanic/Latino share than St John due to port and tourism economy. U.S. Census Bureau — 2010 USVI (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | ~78% White (highest in territory), ~11% Black, ~6% Asian or multiracial — wealthy mainland U.S. in-migration to Cruz Bay corridor. U.S. Census Bureau — 2010 USVI (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | ~79% Black (highest share in territory), ~13% White, Crucian cultural identity distinct from St Thomas. U.S. Census Bureau — 2010 USVI (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Religiondiffers | Protestant majority with active Baptist and Anglican congregations; Catholic minority; cruise-ship port brings diverse visitors. U.S. Census Bureau — 2010 USVI (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | Protestant and Catholic congregations; national-park community with lower church density than St Thomas. U.S. Census Bureau — 2010 USVI (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | ~59% Protestant, ~34% Catholic — strong Catholic presence linked to historic Danish colonial influence. U.S. Census Bureau — 2010 USVI (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Taxes | |||
| Top income tax rate | 37% top marginal (USVI mirror code) USVI Bureau of Internal Revenue (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | 37% top marginal (USVI mirror code) USVI Bureau of Internal Revenue (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | 37% top marginal (USVI mirror code) USVI Bureau of Internal Revenue (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Income tax bandsdiffers | Same USVI mirror brackets as territory-wide. BIR filing required for territorial residents. Federal EITC and child credits mirror U.S. where applicable. USVI Bureau of Internal Revenue (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | USVI mirror of U.S. federal brackets. St John residents file with BIR; no separate island surcharge. USVI Bureau of Internal Revenue (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | USVI mirror of U.S. federal brackets. Largest USVI island — same territorial tax code as St Thomas/St John. USVI Bureau of Internal Revenue (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Transport | |||
| Ferry linksdiffers | St John (20 min) — Varlack Ventures / Transportation Services; St Croix (90 min (inter-island)) — Seaborne Airlines / ferry operators | St Thomas (20 min) — Varlack Ventures / Transportation Services | St Thomas (90 min (inter-island)) — Seaborne Airlines / ferry operators |
Shareable URL: /compare?islands=st-thomas,st-john,st-croix&passport=US
U.S. Virgin Islands for families — school list and summaries
School tuition and healthcare access change. Verify with schools and providers directly. Disclaimer