Compare islands
Side-by-side relocation data with passport filter. Use family focus for schools and daily logistics.
Select 2–5 islands to compare
Maximum of 5 islands — deselect one to add another.
Balearic Islands
Canary Islands
U.S. Virgin Islands
Isle of Man
Galápagos Islands
St Lucia
Tasmania
Antarctic coast islands
Aleutian Islands
Andaman Islands
Scottish Islands
Hawaiian Islands
United States Islands
Remote islands
China Islands
Popular tourist islands
20 fields differ across these islands — highlighted below.
Swipe or scroll sideways to compare islands
| Field | St Lucia | Mallorca |
|---|---|---|
| Residency | ||
| Residency (US passport)differs | Visa-free entry (short stay): U.S. citizens enter visa-free for tourism/business. On arrival, visitors are typically allowed up to 6 weeks. Longer stays require a permit to remain or work permit from the Immigration Department (Castries or Vieux Fort). · verified 2026-06-11 | Schengen short-stay (90/180): U.S. citizens enter Spain visa-free for up to 90 days in any 180-day Schengen period. Balearic Islands use the same Spanish immigration system — longer stays need a national visa (non-lucrative, digital nomad, work, etc.) before relocating. · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Education | ||
| Schools (K–12)differs | International School Saint Lucia; Bonne Terre Preparatory School; St Mary's College (Catholic secondary) verified 2026-06-11 | Bellver International College; Agora Portals International School; Colegio Juan XXIII (Palma) verified 2026-06-11 |
| Early years (preschool / nursery)differs | International School Saint Lucia; Bonne Terre Preparatory School verified 2026-06-11 | None documented on island |
| Higher educationdiffers | St Mary's College (Catholic secondary) verified 2026-06-11 | Bellver International College verified 2026-06-11 |
| Overview | ||
| Populationdiffers | 168,462 CIA World Factbook — Saint Lucia (2025 est.) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | 920,605 IBESTAT — Balearic Islands population 2024 (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Healthcare | ||
| Hospital on island | Yes — full hospital on island Government of Saint Lucia — Owen King EU Hospital (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | Yes — full hospital on island Hospital Universitari Son Espases (Palma) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Evacuation notesdiffers | Two public hospital systems: Owen King EU Hospital (Castries, 122 beds) and St Jude Hospital (south, rebuilding at Augier site). Complex specialty care may require transfer to Barbados, Martinique, or mainland U.S. U.S. Embassy — Medical assistance in St Lucia (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | Son Espases (Palma) is the main tertiary referral centre. Complex paediatric or transplant cases may transfer to Barcelona or Valencia mainland. Servei de Salut de les Illes Balears (IB-SALUT) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Cost of living | ||
| Rent band (monthly, USD)differs | $800–$1,800/mo (2BR; Rodney Bay premium vs south) Numbeo — Rodney Bay cost of living (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | €1,100–€2,200/mo (2BR Palma; lower inland, higher seafront) Idealista — Palma rentals (2025–26) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Groceries vs mainland USdiffers | 20–35% above U.S. average (import-dependent) Central Statistics Office of Saint Lucia (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | Near mainland Spain average; island freight adds modest premium IBESTAT — consumer price indices (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Island cost premiumdiffers | Moderate–high; most consumer goods imported. North coast (Rodney Bay) commands housing premium. Numbeo — Saint Lucia country profile (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | High in Palma and coastal zones — Balearic housing law caps some rents; seasonal tourism affects availability Numbeo — Palma de Mallorca (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Connectivity | ||
| Fiber available | Yes FLOW Saint Lucia (ISP) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | Yes Movistar — fibre coverage Spain (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Typical internet speeddiffers | 50–200 Mbps (fiber in Rodney Bay / Castries; rural varies) FLOW Saint Lucia (ISP) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | 300–600 Mbps fibre in Palma and major towns Ookla Speedtest — Balearic Islands (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Climate & risk | ||
| Hurricane / cyclone exposurediffers | High — Atlantic hurricane season (Jun–Nov). Direct hits possible; infrastructure recovery can take months. NOAA National Hurricane Center (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | Low — Mediterranean climate; occasional severe storms (gota fría) and drought; not hurricane-prone AEMET — Baleares forecast (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Daily life | ||
| Language(s)differs | English (official); Saint Lucian Creole (Kwéyòl) widely spoken CIA World Factbook — Saint Lucia (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | Catalan and Spanish (co-official); English common in Palma expat areas Govern de les Illes Balears (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Car necessitydiffers | Essential — limited public transit; steep interior roads; north–south drives ~1 hr Saint Lucia Tourism Authority (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | Recommended outside Palma metro — TIB buses serve towns but frequencies drop in rural Tramuntana Transports de les Illes Balears (TIB) (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Property | ||
| Foreign property ownershipdiffers | Non-citizens need an Alien Land Holding Licence (Ministry of Finance). Restrictions apply in some coastal zones. Government of Saint Lucia — Alien Land Holding Licence (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | Non-EU buyers allowed with NIE; Balearic Law 6/2023 restricts some tourist rentals — verify before buying investment property Govern Balear — tourist accommodation rules (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Demographics | ||
| Age profilediffers | Median age ~38 (2024 estimate); youthful compared with many Caribbean islands but aging as emigration of working-age adults continues. CIA World Factbook — Saint Lucia (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | Palma metro younger (~40s); interior and north-coast towns older; large German and British retiree cohorts. INE Spain — Balearic Islands (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Ethnic / cultural backgrounddiffers | ~85% Black, ~11% mixed, ~2% East Indian, small White and other minorities (CIA estimate). Kwéyòl (Creole) culture alongside English official identity. CIA World Factbook — Saint Lucia (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | Spanish majority; significant German, British, and Nordic resident communities; Moroccan and Latin American service workers in tourism. INE Spain — Balearic Islands (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Religiondiffers | ~62% Roman Catholic, ~26% Protestant (Seventh-day Adventist, Pentecostal, Baptist), smaller Rastafarian and other groups. CIA World Factbook — Saint Lucia (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | Roman Catholic festivals (Sant Joan, patron saints); secular coastal resort culture; active Muslim community in Palma. INE Spain (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Taxes | ||
| Top income tax ratediffers | 30% top marginal Inland Revenue Department — Saint Lucia (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | 47% combined marginal ceiling (state + Balearic regional, 2025) Agencia Tributaria — Spanish IRPF withholding tables (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Income tax bandsdiffers | E.C. $0–$10,000: 0% E.C. $10,001–$20,000: 10% E.C. $20,001–$30,000: 15% E.C. $30,001–$50,000: 20% Over E.C. $50,000: 30% Eastern Caribbean dollar (XCD) bands; verify IRC Saint Lucia for current thresholds. Inland Revenue Department — Saint Lucia (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 | Spain IRPF: state scale 9.5%–23.5% plus Balearic autonomic surcharge. State bands (2025): 9.5% to €12,450; 12% to €20,200; 15% to €35,200; 18.5% to €60,000; 22.5% to €300,000; 23.5% above. Regional Balearic rates add roughly 8.5%–25% on slices (varies by band). Personal minimum and family allowances reduce taxable base. Wealth tax and local property charges may apply separately. Agencia Tributaria — Spanish IRPF withholding tables (opens in new tab) · verified 2026-06-11 |
| Transport | ||
| Ferry linksdiffers | No ferry required — has airport | Menorca (~3.5 hr (fast ferry) or ~5 hr) — Trasmediterránea / Baleària; Ibiza (~2 hr (fast ferry)) — Baleària / Trasmediterránea |
Shareable URL: /compare?islands=st-lucia,mallorca&passport=US
St Lucia for families — school list and summaries
School tuition and healthcare access change. Verify with schools and providers directly. Disclaimer